How Rory McIlroy defied the odds by winning this year’s Masters

By , Senior Digital Writer. Middle-aged Statto.

History dictates that after this year’s round one, we should have ruled out 89 contenders. But why?

Just because something has never happened doesn’t mean it won’t.

But to rewrite the history books at any of sport’s iconic events requires something out of the ordinary.

The Masters is no exception.

The past quarter of a century has seen Sunday’s eventual champion follow a fairly narrow path as they progress toward the title, rarely leading the way after Thursday’s opening round, but never letting the early pacemaker out of sight.

It’s for this reason that we can predict with a little more confidence than our pre-tournament speculations who may be in contention after a further 36 holes, and more bullishly, who has likely run their race.

The Masters: Champion vs Round 1 Leader

YearWinning ScoreWinnerWinner’s R1 Score (Pos)R1 Leader(s)R1 Leader Score
2025-11Rory McIlroyE (6)Justin Rose-7
2024-11Scottie Scheffler-6 (2)Bryson DeChambeau-7
2023-12Jon Rahm-7 (1) Viktor Hovland, Brooks Koepka, Jon Rahm-7
2022-10Scottie Scheffler-3 (3)Sung-jae Im-5
2021-10Hideki Matsuyama-3 (2)Justin Rose-7
2020-20Dustin Johnson-7 (1)Paul Casey, Dylan Frittelli, Dustin Johnson-7
2019-13Tiger Woods-2 (5)Bryson DeChambeau, Brooks Koepka-6
2018-15Patrick Reed-3 (4)Jordan Spieth-6
2017-9Sergio Garcia-1 (4)Charley Hoffman-7
2016-5Danny Willett-2 (9)Jordan Spieth-6
2015-18Jordan Spieth-8 (1)Jordan Spieth-8
2014-8Bubba Watson-3 (2)Bill Haas-4
2013-9Adam Scott-3 (10)Sergio Garcia, Marc Leishman-6
2012-10Bubba Watson-3 (4)Lee Westwood-5
2011-14Charl Schwartzel-3 (7)Rory McIlroy, Alvaro Quiros-7
2010-16Phil Mickelson-5 (2)Fred Couples-6
2009-12Angel Cabrera-4 (6)Chad Campbell-7
2008-8Trevor Immelman-4 (1)Trevor Immelman, Justin Rose-4
20071Zach Johnson-1 (5)Justin Rose, Brett Wetterich-3
2006-7Phil Mickelson-2 (4)Vijay Singh-5
2005-12Tiger Woods+2 (8)Chris DiMarco-5
2004-9Phil MickelsonE (5)Justin Rose-5
2003-7Mike Weir-2 (4)Darren Clarke-6
2002-12Tiger Woods-2 (7)Davis Love III-5
2001-16Tiger Woods-2 (6)Chris DiMarco-7
2000-10Vijay SinghE (10)Dennis Paulson-4
Average-2.96 (4.5)2.84

What does it tell us, then?

  1. On only four occasions in the last 25 years has the eventual champion been leading or in a tie for the lead after day one.
  2. The average round one score of the eventual champion is 3-under-par, typically sitting just inside the top 5 on the leaderboard.
  3. The eventual champion has never been lower than 10th after round one throughout this period.
  4. Only twice in the last 25 years has the eventual champion clawed back a deficit of more than five shots after day one – Tiger Woods in 2005 (7) and Sergio Garcia in 2017 (6).
  5. The eventual champion is (on average) three shots off the lead after round one, with four shots being the most frequently occurring deficit.
Aaron Rai got off to an incredible start in the 2025 Masters

Who can we rule out based on the above?

If we are to back the Augusta storyline once again in 2025, we can discount any player outside the top 10 after round one and lean strongly toward those who are inside the top 5 and within four shots of the lead. And while the round one leader rarely goes on to claim the Green Jacket, it doesn’t seem right discounting them, especially with two round one leaders going on to win in the last five years.

So, by this (slightly questionable) logic, let’s have some fun and rule out 89 of the 95 players in the field, thereby meaning our 2025 Masters champion will be one of:

  • Justin Rose
  • Scottie Scheffler
  • Ludvig Aberg
  • Corey Conners
  • Bryson DeChambeau
  • Tyrrell Hatton

And as for Rory McIlroy’s latest attempt to complete the career slam. We fear it may be looking like just that. Woods, Mickelson, and Garcia are the only names since 2000 to prove otherwise!

Oh wait…

- Just so you know, we may receive a commission or other compensation from the links on this website - read why you should trust us.